October 2026 News – Talking, or Not, About Interfaith Family Inclusion; Responding Posivitively, or Not, to Interfaith Marriage

|

This month’s newsletter is early because we’re going on a trip to Morocco. Two topics have come up this month: whether leaders and organizations are talking – or not – about interfaith family inclusion, and whether Jews are responding positively – or not – to interfaith marriage.

The third season of Nobody Wants This has dropped; stories have already appeared in the Forward, JTA, Kveller, Hey Alma, Unpacked, Primetimer, and MEAWW. We haven’t had a chance to watch yet, and will plan to cover all of the reaction next month.

Let’s Talk About It – or Not

The Reform Movement. We often point out when interfaith family inclusion could have or should have been discussed, but was not. For example, we had been told by URJ staff that there would not be any programs about interfaith family inclusion at the upcoming Reform movement biennial in December. So we were pleased to learn that there will in fact be a session, co-led by 18Doors’ Rabbi Miriam Wajnberg and Rabbi Ari Perten from Mem Global, about “Welcoming Isn’t Enough: Why Multi-Heritage Families Still Feel Like They Don’t Belong” (programs aren’t listed yet on the website). That was very welcome news – it’s important for the movement not to be complacent, and to do what it can to increase from the current 13% the numbers of interfaith families who are synagogue members.

The Federation World. At the upcoming JFNA General Assembly in November, there will be a session on belonging (on the website look for Monday at 9 am programs):

Everyone wants to build Jewish communities where people feel they belong. Over the past several years, we have invested in new ways of creating connection, welcoming people with different identities and experiences, and designing Jewish life around the needs of a changing community. But what have we learned—and are we seeing the results we hoped for? This conversation will take an honest look at where we are today in fostering belonging. What is working, what is not, and what the next chapter of belonging in Jewish life should look like.

It’s not clear that interfaith families will be part of the discussion. The speakers include several federation officials, including the JFNA’s Rabbi Isaiah Rothstein who directs the Center for Jewish Belonging.

There’s another interesting sounding session, about “Opening New Doors and Expanding Pathways to Education” (on the on the website look for Monday at 2:45 programs) which will address “a remarkable opportunity” to bring day school and camp experiences “to many more children and families.” It’s not clear whether interfaith families and their children are part of that opportunity.

Related to the GA, the JFNA released a new survey about the “surge” in Jewish engagement post-October 7, which was covered by eJP and JTA. Top-line data and a slide deck are available.

Over a year ago, we said in our September 2025 newsletter that when JFNA started doing surveys on the surge, they included data on its impact on the engagement of various minority populations, including LGBTQ Jews, Jews of color, Jews with disabilities, financially vulnerable Jews, and, on at least one occasion, on mixed heritage couples. We didn’t see any mention of how minority populations have been impacted in the latest survey release. We were told that JFNA needed to look at that data; it doesn’t seem likely that it will be reported on at the GA.

Project Prism. In last month’s newsletter we wrote about the Project Prism study of young adults funded by the Jim Joseph Foundation. We noted that 21% of respondents said that a “more welcoming or inclusive atmosphere” was a driver of increased relevance and appeal. We expressed interest in knowing whether respondents from interfaith families (58% of the sample) or who were in interfaith relationships said that that meant a more welcoming or inclusive atmosphere with respect to people like them. We’ve been told that further analyses of the data are underway, and look forward to learning more.

David Cygielman, leader of Mem Global, wrote an interesting piece for eJP about how the Project Prism research supports Mem Global’s strategy to build flexible, informal and low pressure home-based spaces. He notes the research finding that to participate in Jewish experiences that create belonging, young adults must already have some sense of connection, but says it’s a “chicken-egg” problem: many young adults don’t have “formative” experiences that contribute to feelings of connection. He asks, “[W]hat about young adults who reach their 20s or 30s without ‘formative’ experiences like day school, summer camp or engagement on college campuses that contribute to feelings of connection?”

It was striking to me that no mention was made of young adults who have one Jewish parent, or who are partnered with people from different faith backgrounds, and how that may factor into their feelings of belonging. Perhaps they don’t feel like outsiders? Perhaps in Mem Global’s informal settings they don’t experience any negativity about interfaith relationships? Perhaps not many are partnered yet? These would be interesting questions to pursue.

Responding Positively – or Not

Embark. There was another nice article about Mem Global’s Embark program for interfaith couples, this one about an Atlanta cohort. We loved that Rabbi Daniel Dorsch, who leads Conservative Congregation Etz Chayim in Marietta, said: “I hope that the program teaches interfaith couples that there is a space for them in organized Jewish life, not only in a synagogue, but also that there is a rabbi who cares about them and welcomes them into the fold with open arms.”

Conflicted Father. An essay by a very conflicted father about how he treated his son who intermarried – “My son didn’t walk away from Judaism. I walked away from him” – reveals a lot about lingering negative attitudes toward interfaith marriage that some Jews still have. The author is a Jewish American journalist, a self-described “practicing Jew” and son of a Holocaust survivor. He felt it his duty “to keep the chain of our family’s Jewish ancestry from breaking.” His son Ben married a Cuban woman who is not Jewish.

The author initially felt “emotionally wounded, defeated.” He had prayed Ben, who went to Hebrew school and had a bar mitzvah, would marry someone Jewish, but he understood the consequences of living in a multicultural world, and hadn’t objected when Ben brought home girlfriends who weren’t Jewish, or made his expectations clear.

For him, the “question was how to respond when one of your loved ones makes a central life decision that goes against the core of who you are.” At his first meeting with the couple, he was sullen, barely said a word. He turned into an “ethnocentric tribalist, … feeling betrayed, even insulted.” He would “hear the voices of my ancestors, my parents, aunts and uncles, judging me for letting someone in my family ‘stray’ outside the fold.”

Ben had two sons, the author’s grandsons, “both of whom had brises and were given Hebrew names, a process that [Ben and his wife] chose together after exploring their meaning and finding ways to honor Ben’s grandfathers. About those steps to becoming part of a Jewish community, he says, “I wanted more…  [T]hey lived in a town without a synagogue, the closest two hours away.”

Ten years on, he felt under a “cloud of sadness,” “disappointed in a reality that continues challenging me to accept my son’s choices.” When he and Ben finally started talking about it, Ben said, “I don’t want to say I regret my marriage in any way. But as I’ve gotten older and probably especially now that I have kids, and post Oct. 7th, this has carried more meaning than in my mid-20s. Should I have married Jewish? Probably. Did I let you (and my grandparents) down? Likely.” But he also said he was not “abandoning his connection to our community,” had put “much thought, effort and wrestling … into his relationship with Judaism,” and searched for ways to connect them to their Jewish roots.

The author realizes that his son hadn’t left, had kept inviting him closer; it was the author who had “stepped back from the warmth and called it loyalty to my ancestors, to the tradition.” He still struggles with his fears “that I’ve let the chain break.” But he wants to be a different father, to love his son back.

Our two observations: first, Jewish parents making their expectations clear that they want their children to marry Jews, in many if not most cases, will not only not prevent interfaith marriage, but will instead risk pushing the interfaith couples from Jewish engagement. People who are told a community disapproves of what they did will not want to engage with that community.

Second, what strikes us most here is the father thinking that what’s important is whether his son’s spouse is Jewish – not whether his son’s family and children are Jewishly engaged. He thinks that the act of intermarrying itself is disloyal to the tradition, strays from the fold, “breaks the chain.” He seems oblivious that interfaith families can and do engage with and continue the tradition; he is unsatisfied that his grandchildren look like they will in fact be part of the chain. He only starts to realize after ten years that because of the sadness and disapproval he thought was loyalty to the tradition, he missed the opportunity to love his son’s family, to embrace them – and to support and encourage their engagement with that tradition.

Stephen Flatow. Another flawed statement came from Stephen Flatow, a prominent Jewish leader whose daughter was murdered in a Palestinian terror attack in 1995. In “Zionism needs no progressive permission” he defends religious Zionism as worthy of support by progressives, in addition to “secular, liberal, democratic Zionism.” In doing so, he says that much of American Jewish life has moved for generations towards an identity “defined increasingly by ethnicity, culture, politics and family memory rather than religious observance, Jewish learning and obligation.”

There is a lot to be said for Mr. Flatow’s argument that transmission of Jewish identity needs or is certainly strengthened by the religious aspects of Judaism. Unfortunately, he bases his argument on the high rate of interfaith marriage the low rate of raising children Jewish by religion among the intermarried, stating that the American Jewish “experiment” has not worked.

He says that the figures “do not prove that cultural Judaism causes intermarriage or that intermarriage alone creates a weaker Jewish identity. Pew warns against drawing that conclusion.” But then he says that “People whose Jewish identity is already weaker may simply be more likely to marry non-Jews.”

He also says that not “every Jew must become Orthodox,” that an intermarried Jew is not less worthy, and that children from intermarried families should not be pushed away. “Quite the opposite: All Jews should be welcomed and encouraged to deepen their connection to the Jewish people.”

Mr. Flatow doesn’t get it. Trashing interfaith marriage effectively expresses that intermarried Jews are less worthy. It completely undermines the effort to welcome interfaith families and encourage them to deepen their connection that Mr. Flatow says he supports.

In Other News

  • An interesting blog post by a Karaite Jew about their approach to patrilineality
  • Not one, but two articles about what sounds like a very interesting play that just opened in Winnipeg about an interfaith couple having their first child after fifteen years trying to decide about circumcision
  • Not sure what to make of this: a “vampire comedy” allegory for interfaith marriage involving marrying into a rich vampire family.

September 2026 News – Embark, Matrilineality, Reform Movement, Rabbi Al Axelrad

|

I hope your holidays have been meaningful in our very challenging world. It’s been quiet with respect to interfaith family inclusion; a few items reflect a wide range of attitudes towards interfaith marriage.

Embark: Embracing Interfaith Couples

The best piece this month was in the Philadelphia Jewish Exponent about a new Embark cohort there, led by Rabbi Megan GoldMarche, a campus rabbi at Penn Hillel. Embark is featured in our July newsletter. Run by Mem Global, it is “a program for interfaith and mixed-heritage couples who want Judaism to be part of their household. It is not a conversion class, though it shares qualities and lessons with one.”

I love what Rabbi GoldMarche, who aims to show interfaith couples that Jewish life is “accessible,” says:

More importantly than whether Jews marry Jews is whether we raise Jews. The people who are going to keep Judaism alive aren’t all going to be Jewish.

The goal is for the couple to be able to have a Jewish home together. I think we all know these days that you can have a Jewish home even if one person in the couple is not Jewish…. They can live a rich Jewish life whether they convert or not.

Identity – Challenged By Matrilineality

In “I came to America as a Jewish refuge. For some Jews, I still don’t count,” Radmilla Suleymanova, an immigrant from Turkmenistan, tells a powerful story.

Raised as a Jew by her father who is Jewish and her mother who is not, even attending Orthodox yeshivas as a child, her extended family did not consider her Jewish. But she “felt a deep connection with my Jewish roots” and felt deeply that “The Diary of Anne Frank” and “Schindler’s List” were “the history of my people.” She visited concentration camps, went on Birthright trips, yet “All the while, I carried a sense that my identity was being rejected or denied.”

[M]any Jews I encountered kept reminding me that, because my mother was not Jewish, they did not consider me Jewish either. I felt pushed out and repeatedly reminded that I was the other. Not good enough. Not one of us.

She considered conversion, but it “presented a contradiction. It would have required me to approach Judaism as an outsider, and I had never experienced myself that way. I didn’t need a stamp or diploma to become what I already was.” Conversion “was about conceding that everything I had loved until then somehow did not belong to me. I wasn’t willing to do that.”

Suleymanova is realistic, respectful, and assertive:

I understand that some Jews will never consider me Jewish. They are entitled to their beliefs, but not to rewrite my childhood or my inheritance.

I am not asking every Jewish community to bend the rules for me. But I do think the children of Jewish men get a raw deal. Jewish fathers are very influential in the home. They often set the tone, raise their children Jewish, share customs and histories. Fathers pass down identity.

I no longer need anyone to tell me what I am and whether I belong. I know what I inherited. I know who I am.

The Reform Movement: Positive – and Proactive?

There was another nice piece in the Philadelphia Jewish Exponent – an interview with Rabbi Rick Jacobs, who had some very positive things to say about interfaith marriage. (I didn’t love the way the Exponent posed the question: “Intermarriage rates are at record highs in the U.S. How can we still find ways to build strong Jewish homes in this environment?”)

Rabbi Alexander Schindler’s stance to lovingly embrace interfaith families was “the most brilliant shift… [looking] back, absolutely critical.”

The “idea that intermarriage looks like decline is a mistaken assumption.”

We have focused on bringing interfaith families into the mainstream of Jewish life and we are now succeeding…. We are now the largest movement. Part of the reason is our embrace of interfaith families.

There are things that a couple can do that increase the sense of belonging. We show up with arms extended.

I have questioned whether the Reform movement is coasting on its laurels, or proactively planning to do more to attract more interfaith families. At the time  of our June newsletter, at the upcoming biennial there were no sessions that would specifically be about interfaith family inclusion (although I was told “many sessions will be relevant.”) I said that only 13% of interfaith families belong to synagogues, and that for a synagogue movement, that data should be a spur to focused action. After the original version of this blog was posted on September 30, I was pleased to learn that there will be a session, co-led by 18Doors’ Rabbi Miriam Wajnberg and Rabbi Ari Perten from Mem Global, called “Welcoming Isn’t Enough: Why Multi-Heritage Families Still Feel Like They Don’t Belong.”

Let’s Talk About It – or Not?

A beloved rabbi, Al Axelrad, died recently. A very nice obituary in JTA described him as an early pluralist, founder of a havurah, advocate to end the war in Vietnam and divest from South Africa, activist to free Soviet Jews, and creator of adult bar/bat mitzvahs. It neglected to mention that Rabbi Axelrad was a pioneer in officiating at weddings of interfaith couples.

The obituary in the Boston Globe did mention it: “A passionate advocate for interfaith understanding and marriage, he believed that supportive partners and spouses of different faiths could strengthen Jewish families, the Jewish population and community life all around.”

His Wikipedia entry adds:

Beginning in the first years of his rabbinate, Axelrad advocated for rabbinic officiation at marriages of a Jew and a non-Jew, although only under limited circumstances. Noting that supportive non-Jewish spouses could be involved in raising Jewish children, he proposed that rabbis should be understanding of a non-Jewish partner’s reluctance to convert to Judaism for any of a variety of reasons. For couples willing to raise Jewish children, Axelrad proposed that the cooperation and support of a rabbi at the outset of the marriage could be crucial in their decision to do so.

Rabbi Axelrad was supportive in the early years of InterfaithFamily (now 18Doors). I’m sure his memory is a blessing for many, many people.

Unclear, Seems Negative

Phoebe Maltz Bovy, opinion editor of the Canadian Jewish News, refers to “October 8 endogamists” – young Jewish women who want to date only Jewish men because they are experiencing antisemitism (or anti-Zionism). To the extent this is accurate and prevalent, it is a sad development.

Bovy makes an interesting observation about her own experience: “Birthright Israel was, I learned while participating, about finding a Jewish partner with whom to make Jewish babies.”

She seems to be negative about interfaith marriage: “Throughout history, Jewish family lines have assimilated out of the Jewish people via such marriages, often with the Jewish spouse converting out.”

The Traditional Perspective – Interfaith Marriage = the End of Judaism

An Orthodox media outlet, the Jewish Press, had a story about Todd Brody, who started a website, ChoosingTheChosenLife.com, to publicize stories of people who became traditionally observant. Brody espouses the traditional view:

I realized that if I didn’t make a change, my children might not marry Jews. And if they didn’t, then Judaism in my family line could end with me. That thought shook me.

We talk about Jewish continuity, but for many Jews, the reality is that without observance, the likelihood of intermarriage skyrockets. And once that happens, within a generation or two, the Jewish identity fades. I didn’t want to be the link in the chain where it broke.

Becoming observant wasn’t just about my own spiritual growth. It was about ensuring that my children, grandchildren, and great‑grandchildren would be part of the Jewish future.

In Other News

Season Three of Nobody Wants This is coming this month. The first eight paragraphs of a Times of Israel blog post, “Put Me Down for Outrage,” makes the interesting point that “the show asks Joanne, and, by extension, the audience, to take Noah’s Jewish commitments seriously.” (The rest of the post is critical of the way actor Adam Brody talked in an interview about the conflict in Gaza.)

April 2026 News: Will 18Doors Crisis Be Opportunity for Funders To Do the Right Thing?

|

A Personal Note

In this newsletter I recap the month’s developments and news related to inclusion of interfaith families in Jewish life.

A lot happened this month, starting with something personal – with a big interfaith family inclusion angle – my granddaughter’s bat mitzvah this month at Mishkan Chicago.

I’m still glowing from the overwhelming joy I felt. My granddaughter is a beautiful person, inside and out. She did a wonderful job that made her loving family very proud.

Tazria Metzora may be the most dreaded b mitzvah Torah portion. It’s about how people with skin afflictions (translated as leprosy) are treated, and the text is pretty gross. My granddaughter declined my offers to help her with her d’var Torah. She decided to speak about how we treat people who are different or other.

You’ll understand how I was so deeply moved when she said, “often people who aren’t Jewish and who are raising kids within the Jewish community feel othered or judged. My mom has supported me in my Jewish upbringing to get me here today. So we need to appreciate everyone in the community and make room for all of us.”

I was also deeply grateful to my daughter-in-law’s supportive family – her Quaker mother, who I overheard proudly presenting my granddaughter with a book about Jewish women, and her sisters, who opened and closed the Ark, and a nephew who was able to attend.

Rabbis Lizzi Heydemann and Steven Philp are models of inclusivity. My son mentioned the Quaker faith when speaking to my granddaughter. I think many rabbis would have cringed at even the mention of a different faith. But R’Lizzi a few minutes later ran towards it, commenting that we were about to say a prayer, the Amidah, which involved an opportunity for silence like what is common in Quaker services.

On the personal, individual level, there is so much reason for hope: interfaith families that find living Jewishly compelling; families from different faith backgrounds who are supportive; rabbis who “get it.”

On the organizational, institutional level this month, not so much reason for hope, sadly.

18Doors and the Funding Community

On April 7 JTA broke the story, “National support group for interfaith Jewish families guts staff amid funding crisis,” that was reprinted widely in the Forward, Jerusalem Post, Times of Israel, and Jweekly. 18Doors, the organization I founded as InterfaithFamily, laid off more than two-thirds of its staff due to a funding shortfall.

I have no formal connection to the organization. My understanding is that there are discussions about finding homes in other organizations for some of 18Doors’ programs, and about possibly continuing as a smaller organization focused on field building; at this writing, the future is not clear.

On April 10 eJP published my op-ed, “From crisis to opportunity: Now is the time for a serious effort to engage interfaith families.” I said the news was personally devastating, and a loss to the thousands of interfaith families the organization serves and the many Jewish leaders who benefit from its resources and training.

(Coincidentally, at my granddaughter’s bat mitzvah, Rabbi Heydemann told the congregation that InterfaithFamily had helped to change the climate around interfaith families finding rabbis to officiate at their weddings, and Rabbi Philp told me that his participation in 18Doors’ Rukin Fellowship that trains rabbis to be inclusive was very helpful to him.)

I also wrote that the news was an indictment of the funding community which has never adequately funded efforts to engage interfaith families Jewishly.

I’m proud of the work InterfaithFamily and then 18Doors did over the years. We moved the needle towards more interfaith families being more Jewishly engaged to a degree – but not far enough.

As JTA reported, while the rate of interfaith marriage has increased since 2001, most children from these marriages are being raised Jewish, with participation in synagogues and Jewish institutions common. Two seminaries now admit students in interfaith relationships, and the Conservative movement seeks to be more inclusive. For the most part, Jewish leaders, at least in America, are not railing against interfaith marriage.

But far fewer interfaith than inmarried couples are synagogue members, or provide their children with Jewish education. My recent review of a dozen years of national and local Jewish community studies shows that interfaith families feel much less of a sense of belonging to the Jewish people or their local Jewish communities, and some number of interfaith couples still feel like “outsiders” and “other.” Helping interfaith couples and the partners from different faith backgrounds to feel that sense of belonging, essential to their Jewish engagement, remains the challenge of our time.

At least five federations in their recent community studies have stated that it is essential to engage interfaith families [which] requires a strong investment…. So far, that investment has not been forthcoming. Today, only one community, Cleveland, has a robust local program, jHub, that explicitly serves interfaith families with a broad array of services. Every sizeable community should have a similar program, and they should be networked together with a central national organization that also provides resources and training to professionals and lay leaders who want to be inclusive.

I hope that 18Doors can be or play an important role in the kind of national network that is needed — and that the funding community will take the opportunity presented by 18Doors’ crisis to finally fund a serious effort to engage interfaith families. It’s nearly 20 years overdue, but it’s not too late.

Just today, the Cleveland Jewish News has a story about diversity that in part highlights jHub. It quotes a local Jewish professional and says, “the growth of interfaith families and their participation in Jewish life shows the continued celebration of diversity in the community. That said, challenges come along with that, such as being more welcoming to interfaith families in synagogues or religious spaces…. [That’s a challenge that the legacy organizations and the community have to think about.”

Missed Opportunity 1: The Reform movement

Rabbi Esther Lederman, the new head of the URJ’s new Jewish Life & Leadership department, wrote a very nice essay for eJP, “‘I Will Be What I Will Be’: A Futuring Stance.” At one point she says, “The multiplicity of diverse Jewish identities, from racial and ethnic backgrounds to sexual orientation, gender identities, economic backgrounds and neurodiversity, is astounding and beautiful. It is a future that will be richer for encompassing the lived experiences of a greater number of individuals of diverse backgrounds and unique perspectives.”

This was a missed opportunity, perhaps inadvertent, to mention diverse faith backgrounds – which actually is by far the largest diversity in the American Jewish community, and the Reform community in particular. The leaders of the Reform movement seem to think that interfaith family inclusion is at the center of its work because it was pioneered by the movement, and that they have been successful at it, so they don’t need to talk about or prioritize doing anything about it.

But only 13% of interfaith families belong to synagogues. I wouldn’t be satisfied with that level of success.

MIssed Opportunity 2: PJ Library

Lara Knuettel, chief philanthropy officer of PJ Library, wrote a very nice essay for eJP, “It’s On All of Us To Share the Stories of the Jewish People.” She describes a recent PJ Library event where “children could choose books with characters who reflected a full range of Jewish identities and histories” including books in or including Spanish, Russian, Hebrew, Yiddish, and Ladino, and showing Shabbat celebrated in different ways, but with no mention of children in interfaith families.

I agree 100% with what Kneuttel says:

[T]he stories we tell shape how our children see themselves, who they become, and how they engage with the world. The stories we elevate signal who belongs, whose voices matter, and how children come to understand both their own identities and those of others…. [S]upporting the stories children have access to is one way to ensure that Jewish life, in all its variety, continues to be celebrated, shared and passed on from generation to generation.

That’s why I wish she had explicitly mentioned children in interfaith families as among those whose stories PJ Library wants to support. Don’t get me wrong: PJ Library is a great organization, and has made efforts to offer books highlighting interfaith families. But my recent review of local Jewish community studies showed that only 28% of eligible interfaith families received PJ Library books compared to 50% of inmarried families. To change that, they need to talk about and market to interfaith families explicitly, like they have for ethnic and gender diversities.

Missed Opportunity 3: Israel

Zvika Klein, the editor-in-chief of The Jerusalem Post, wrote there about how Israel should “speak to people who stand close to the Jewish story, sometimes very close, but do not fit neatly into one box.”

Klein says there are almost nine million people who are eligible to move to Israel under the Law of Return (presumably because they have a Jewish grandparent) plus “millions” who “seek some form of connection to the Jewish people and the Jewish state.” He says “Israel needs future citizens, loyal friends, serious allies, informed advocates, students, and fellow travelers” and should “open the door wider” with routes and methods to build attachment with these people: “A country that was built to gather exiles should be better at recognizing the people standing near the edge of the camp, waiting to see whether anyone inside is ready to speak to them.”

Yet another missed opportunity: nothing said about the partners from different faith backgrounds married to Jews. Is it unreasonable to expect “one of the world’s top journalists specializing in Jewish Diaspora affairs,” as the Post describes Klein, to say something explicit about that very large group?

Inclusion Is Hard Work

People will engage in a group if they feel that they belong. Being helped to feel belonging is hard – it means being received for who you are, not who the group wants you to become. In Clal’s Wisdom Daily, Reverend Jill Harman explained:

There are spaces that open their doors and make me feel received, and then there are spaces that open their doors but already have a shape in mind for who I should become once I step inside. That difference isn’t always obvious at first. Sometimes a place feels warm and generous and full of good people, and sometimes it really is all of those things. And still, over time, something in me begins to notice that the welcome is leaning somewhere. It has a direction to it, a quiet belief that closeness will eventually soften you into someone easier to claim.

That’s where the ache begins: Even when that pressure is gentle, it changes the feeling of the room. Something in me stops being able to rest, because I’m no longer sure whether the kindness is meant for who I am or for who someone hopes I’ll become. That makes it very hard to stay.

I loved that Conservative Rabbi Ben Herman, coincidentally a current 18Doors Rukin Fellow, made a similar point in “Why We Changed the Rules So Non-Jews Can Be Members of Our Synagogue.” Rabbi Herman describes the distinction between being diverse and being inclusive (citing Verna Myers, who coincidentally I used to work with long ago when I was a lawyer): “‘Diversity is being invited to the party; inclusion is being asked to dance.’ Being invited is wonderful, but without agency in the congregation’s decision-making processes, one is not truly included.”

The article relates that, with Rabbi Herman’s support, 75% of the congregation were in favor of adopting changed by-laws under which “Non-Jews in interfaith relationships are now considered full members of the congregation, and patrilineal Jews may serve on the Board of Trustees.” That’s progress.

But 25% against even being considered members – that’s still a lot of opposition. It clearly signals that many in the congregation are hoping that partners from different faith backgrounds will become something else.

Traditional Attitudes in Canada

The same attitude seems prevalent in Canada. The Canadian Jewish News asks “how important is marrying within the faith to singles today?” and reports on new research based on interviews of fifty-one single Canadian Jews about attitudes towards marriage partners. The singles interviewed, and their parents as described by them, all still seem to be coming from a place where what matters in a partner is their being Jewish – not that what matters is a couple and their family engaging in Jewish life regardless of the religious identity of the partner. There’s an assumption that intermarrying will be disappointing to the parents and problematic to the individual.

Along with those traditional attitudes, there is less interfaith marriage in Canada than in the US, but it is steadily increasing. Fern Chertok and Matthew Brookner from the Cohen Center did a study, cited in this research, that showed increasing acceptance of interfaith marriage, but “many of the couples that were interviewed indicate that they feel not fully accepted by the community,” particularly couples with mothers who were not Jewish. Several couples also reported pressure for conversion. One interviewee said, “in some congregations, it feels like if you’re not Jewish, you can come but you can’t really be part of things.”

The Canadian Jewish News also summarizes a new study of intermarriage in Canada, which says, “Our research suggests that, if the Jewish community can recruit more Jewish children to Jewish day schools and summer camps and attract more Jewish immigrants to Canada, the increasing rate of Jewish intermarriage may slow.” The researchers clearly seem to be coming from a perspective that interfaith marriage is undesirable, something to be discouraged if not prevented. They even suggest that increasing antisemitism may slow the intermarriage rate. Increasing antisemitism can’t be a good thing.

In Other News

  • Noah Wyle, star of The Pitt, talks with the British Jewish press about his Jewish background
  • It’s now clear that Season 3 of “Nobody Wants This” will be about conversion – with Sarah Silverman playing the rabbi who leads Joanne’s conversion class.

*****

A sad note: Jim Ball, one of the original board members of InterfaithFamily, died this month. I met Jim nearly forty years ago when we were both involved in the Reform movement’s northeast region outreach committee. A convert himself, he understood the importance of interfaith family inclusion and was always a kind, interesting and helpful board member. Sincere condolences to his wife Anita Diamant and daughter Emilia Diamant.

March 2026 News: How Interested Are Jewish Leaders in Engaging Interfaith Families? Some Talk, and Research Support, But Little Action

|

I was busy this month with three presentations on what’s necessary for interfaith families and partners from different faith backgrounds to feel belonging in Jewish settings: with Cohort 5 of the 18Doors Rukin Fellows on March 10, with students and faculty at a lunch & learn at the Hebrew College Rabbinical School on March 17, and at an Academy for Jewish Religion/CA colloquium of students and alumni on March 30.

But I can’t say, based on this small sample, that Jewish leaders are becoming more interested in engaging interfaith families.

Talk

There is some discussion going on. There was an interesting commentary in the British Jewish press on the US Conservative movement’s recent report on intermarriage, which we’ve discussed at length in previous newsletters. I learned that the European branch of the movement, the International Rabbinical Assembly, is “studying the impact of intermarriage on our communities and assessing whether our traditional responses are achieving their goals or whether different approaches are necessary.”

At the Jewish Funders Network’s conference this month, according to eJP, “the theme of new voices in the philanthropic world was a topic,” and Jonah Platt talked about the opportunity to “start to create new institutions, or reprioritize our current ones in the way that they’re operating, and bring in all these other people who have not been engaged and want to be and don’t necessarily know how or what to do, but want to do it.” But if there was specific talk about engaging interfaith families, it wasn’t reported.

In early March there was an “unconference” in Miami to talk about the renewal of American Jewry. eJP reported that “Many issues already firmly in the Jewish communal zeitgeist came up repeatedly during panels,” including “the importance of better welcoming interfaith families.” An attendee confirmed to me that there appeared to be much interest in interfaith families. But shouldn’t representatives from organizations that work with and advocate for inclusion of interfaith families be included in gatherings of this type if the goal is real progress?

Research

I was pleased to see that the March 25 issue of the CASJE (Collaborative for Applied Studies in Jewish Education) Research Digest featured studies about interfaith families and their children, and that it mentioned our paper, What Recent Studies Reveal About Interfaith Family Inclusion.

The digest points to “a clear trajectory: in the years ahead, a growing share of Jews in the US will have only one Jewish parent;” that “more children of intermarried couples are identifying as Jewish because Jewish institutions became significantly more welcoming and inclusive toward intermarried families starting in the 1980s and 1990s;” and that “participation in Jewish educational opportunities can play a critical role in supporting children of intermarriage growing into adults who identify as Jewish and participate actively in Jewish life.”

These kinds of research results should support more programmatic efforts to be inclusive of interfaith families and to engage their children in Jewish educational activities. Whether they will – not clear.

Inaction/Action

Data in the appendix of a new study by the Cohen Center of 2025 Birthright Israel trips shows that the percentage of trip applicants who indicated that their parents were intermarried (those who did not say “all parents Jewish”) ranged between 33% and 37% between 2017 and 2020, reached a high of 41% in 2021, then declined to 32% in 2022, 29% in 2023, 24% in 2024, and a low of 19% in 2025. Given the trajectory of more Jews having one Jewish parent, it’s clear that Birthright needs to attract more applicants from that category, not fewer.

The study notes that the impact of trip participation appears to be greater among political liberals and on those who come from less engaged Jewish backgrounds, and states that attracting liberal Jews and those with less exposure to Jewish education is key to Birthright’s continued success. But it doesn’t say anything similar, that attracting children from interfaith families is key to Birthright’s continued success.

One concrete positive development this month was “Creating Belonging for Multiheritage Families,” an article by Michelle Barton and 18Doors’ Miriam Wajnberg in the journal of Prizmah, the network of Jewish day schools. The article relates the process by which the Shlenker School in Houston, with help from 18Doors, addressed the question parents raising children in interfaith families can ask: whether their family fully belongs.

“As family structures and Jewish journeys diversify, schools are called to examine whether their policies, cultures, language and rituals truly foster belonging or simply allow participation without full inclusion. Belonging is not synonymous with enrollment or participation. It reflects whether families feel seen, valued and confident that their full identities fit within the life of the school.”

The authors describe three obstacles that interfaith families face to belonging in Jewish communities and day schools: (1) an insider/outsider element; (2) a stigma against those who marry someone from another background; (3) “The belief in matrilineal descent creates barriers for multiheritage families to fully feel a sense of belonging in Jewish communities and schools.” “Even when a child from a multiheritage family may be fully accepted in one denomination or setting, that acceptance may not extend to all Jewish settings, resulting in ‘othering.’”

It is very heartening to see day schools focusing on interfaith family belonging. Almost twenty years ago, in 2007, for the tenth anniversary of the Partnership for Excellence in Jewish Education (which became part of Prizmah in 2016), I wrote “Interfaith Families and the Future of Jewish Day Schools.” I said:

“Schools can make themselves more accessible to these [intermarried] parents by making explicit statements of welcome, couching their specifically Jewish values in universal terms, and providing extra explanatory information on Jewish holidays, rituals and culture.” “Day schools could become laboratories that attempt to resolve the thorny issues of recognition. Every participant in a Jewish day school community could be considered – in some way – part of the Jewish community and people.”

It’s almost twenty years since I said, “Imagine how radically different the future of Jewish day schools would be if even ten percent of this growing population [of interfaith families] chose Jewish day schools.” We’re not even close to that yet – the recent Boston 2025 study found that 1% of children of interfaith families attended day schools compared to 23% of children of inmarried families. Efforts to foster belonging could lead to more enrollment. The many funders who support day schools might consider directing some of their funding to those efforts.

In other news 

I think Mira Fox was too dismissive of something in “Is Goy a Slur, an Antisemitic Dogwhistle or a Word for Non-Jews?” She says “goy” “simply means ‘non-Jew,’ or foreign nation which isn’t inherently insulting; Jews are far from the only group to have a term for outsider – think gringo in Spanish or farang in Thai. This can, of course, be exclusionary. There is certainly the sense that outsiders cannot understand or participate in certain activities of an in-group – an idea that is not limited to Jews. And sometimes that is used to discriminate or insult.”

I say that for people in interfaith relationships, any use of “goy” by Jews not just can be exclusionary, it is exclusionary and makes the partners from different faith backgrounds feel like outsiders. Even if the word has innocent meanings, I think any use of it by Jews is a bad idea.

Also noted:

November 2025 News: Laura Lauder and Embark; Rabbis and Interfaith Marriage in ATRA Study; Nobody Wants This; Chosenness

|

Laura Lauder and Embark

eJP ran an important interview of philanthropist Laura Lauder about the Embark program she launched and supports, now as part of Mem Global. The goal of Embark is “to have [non-Jewish partners] feel comfortable in their identity as a parent of Jewish children and as a member of a Jewish household. …[W]e are here to provide you with an educational experience with a cohort of other people in your same shoes, to enable you to decide for yourself, and whatever you decide, what we hope is that the decision is to make a warm, loving Jewish home and raise your children Jewish.”

The questions by eJP’s Jay Deitcher seem hostile to Lauder’s positions. He asks, “Do you ever fear that changing expectations of children related to interfaith relationships and intermarriage is a mistake? That the community’s leniency has gone too far….” He suggests that Embark does not strengthen Jewish community when he asks, “[S]tudies show that Jews who marry other Jews have stronger engagement with Judaism. Why not focus your effort on pushing for a stricter Judaism, or pushing for day schools or focusing your finances on strengthening the Jewish community?” Even the title given to the interview – “Still preferring Jewish marriages, Laura Lauder pledges $500K annually to boost interfaith couples” – is slanted; Lauder never says that she prefers “Jewish marriages.” The title also begs the question, with a 72% rate of interfaith marriage among non-Orthodox Jews, what is a Jewish marriage today?

Lauder’s position is laudable: “It’s not a conversion program…. [M]y sense is that we have to be inclusive and embrace these families who are interfaith and who want to raise their kids Jewish, so we want to provide a vehicle to enable them to do that.”

The Embark program includes a unit on Israel, about which Lauder says: “[W]e hope that these young people will keep their views on the issue on the Gaza war out of their decision as to how much they want to incorporate Judaism in their lives. I’m hoping that this particular Israeli government doesn’t dissuade them from wanting to have more Judaism in their lives.”

Rabbis and Interfaith Marriage

ATRA released a fascinating study conducted by Rosov Consulting about the rabbinate. Many of the study’s observations relate to interfaith families.

  • Congregations apparently want to be inclusive of interfaith families. In searching for rabbis, “inclusivity is a key characteristic of desired candidates. This inclusivity appears to be aimed at interfaith families … and those who are not halakhically Jewish but still seek to participate in community life. The postings include phrases [that reflect] a need for openness and acceptance. The candidate is characterized as a bridge between tradition and modernity, which requires a personality that is open and adaptable. This focus is clearest in positions aimed at fostering community with younger demographics (e.g., college students), but it is also present in many congregations seeking to remain relevant in a rapidly evolving society.”
  • More rabbis and future rabbis have interfaith backgrounds or relationships; among current rabbinical students, 20% were not raised Jewish or not raised exclusively Jewish. This creates issues for them.
  • Some students were “deterred by concerns, whether true now or not, that some aspect of their identity would disqualify them from being able to attend rabbinical school. Perceptions of how inclusive various rabbinical schools are for … students in interfaith marriages … shaped decisions about where to attend.”
  • “For some interviewees, coming from interfaith or non-Jewish backgrounds created feelings of exclusion and added hurdles in the admissions process. They described concerns that their backgrounds might be scrutinized more heavily, requiring them to prove their Jewish authenticity or justify their place in rabbinical training in ways that peers from more traditional backgrounds did not face.” One comment: “I have one non-Jewish parent, and that is a problem with a lot of people in the Jewish community, especially because it’s my mother. So, there’s plenty in the community who look at that and go, ‘you’re not really Jewish.'”

Nobody Wants This

Rabbi Lisa Rubin, who runs the very successful Center for Exploring Judaism program based at Central Synagogue, had an interesting take on the show, “Conversion isn’t a solo act. So why is the rabbi in ‘Nobody Wants This’ acting alone?” Rubin sees interfaith marriage as “an extraordinary opportunity for growth. Interfaith relationships, approached thoughtfully, can be pathways into Judaism rather than exits from it.” Her main point is that Rabbi Noah shouldn’t have tried to mentor Joanne himself, but rather should have connected her to a program – like the Center for Exploring Judaism – which she describes beautifully. She sees the show’s title as ironic, because “Jews should want this… [W]e should want our communities to see interfaith love not as a threat, but as a chance to expand the circle.”

For more on the Nobody Wants This front, it looks like there will be a season three, but the speculation is that Joanne will convert. I won’t get the show I was hoping to see, about a happily married, Jewishly-engaged, interfaith couple.

Chosenness

The Reconstructionist journal Evolve published an interesting essay by Rabbi Amichai Lau-Lavie about chosenness. At his congregation, Lab/Shul:

“[W]e have replaced the blessing at the Torah with asher bakhartanu im kol ha’amim – ‘Who has chosen us, along with all other peoples, to live this life with love.’ That is because I estimate that a good half of my community is not necessarily Jewish according to Jewish law. They are Jewish, they are Jewish-adjacent, they are people who have chosen to live with Jewish people. Some are Jewish patrilineally. Others, matrilineally. Still others, Jews by choice. We are human, and being Jewish is part of who we are.”

In Other News

  • An article from Religion News Service about how Vice President Vance hopes his Hindu wife converts to Christianity quotes our friend Susan Katz Miller, who aptly says, “To respect your partner and everything they bring to the marriage – every part of their identity – is integral to the kind of honesty that you need to have in a marriage.” And, “pressuring one’s spouse to convert or even hoping they would convert is not a good basis for a successful marriage.”
  • The Jewish Education Project’s otherwise excellent “What Will Jewish Education Look Like in 2050” does not mention any emphasis on reaching or including interfaith families.
  • I was not able to attend the JFNA’s General Assembly. I heard that there was discussion of engaging interfaith families, but have not seen anything published or public on that issue. An essay before the GA talked about “unveiling innovative platforms and programs that foster an inclusive culture and provide opportunities for deeper Jewish learning and involvement for those who may have been disconnected” before October 7. In an interview after the GA, JFNA’s CEO Eric Fingerhut said “There are great opportunities to increase the number of people engaged in Jewish life and education.” It remains to be seen how much priority will be given to engaging interfaith families.

October 2025 News: Lessons from Research on Interfaith Families’ Belonging; What Season Two of Nobody Wants This Gets Right

|

Today’s eJewishPhilanthropy Op-ed: What Research Reveals About Interfaith Families’ Feelings of Belonging

For the first time ever, we held this email newsletter beyond the end of the month, so that we could tell you that today, eJewishPhilanthropy published our op-ed, Making Interfaith Families a Valued Part of Jewish Communities.

We’ve been working for many months on a project to gather and review all of the data on interfaith families’ feelings of belonging in a dozen years’ worth of research: two national Pew reports, twenty-six local community studies by the Cohen Center at Brandeis, one quantitative and three qualitative Cohen Center studies of interfaith families, a recent qualitative study led by Tobin Belzer and a recent local community study by Rosov Consulting.

Today’s op-ed summarizes the Center’s detailed paper, What Recent Studies Reveal About Interfaith Family Inclusion. The paper’s conclusions:

  • people in interfaith relationships do not feel very connected to or part of the Jewish people or their local Jewish community, and significantly less so than inmarrieds do;
  • interfaith families, and partners from different faith backgrounds, want to feel like part of Jewish communities, but instead persistently feel othered and excluded;
  • not having many Jewish friends or knowing many people in the Jewish community may contribute to not feeling belonging, and could be countered by extending personal invitations;
  • policies that restrict participation contribute to not feeling belonging, and policies around diversity and inclusion being made explicit are a welcoming factor; and
  • clear communication that interfaith families are a valued part of the Jewish community is needed to help move interfaith families from othering to belonging.

This was a major effort for the Center and we are grateful to eJewishPhilanthropy for publishing the op-ed and to Rachel Kohn for her careful and helpful editing.

We hope the information contained in the paper will be helpful to everyone who is working to foster more Jewish engagement among interfaith families. We’re very interested in discussing the paper and in your feedback; please contact us at info@cfrij.com

Season Two of Nobody Wants This

There seemed to be a lot of buzz about the show before it was released, but not so much afterwards. My take, in the Times of Israel blogs: What Season Two of Nobody Wants This Gets Right About Interfaith Relationships.

Season two’s messaging is much improved. Most of the negativity about interfaith marriage from the first season is gone. The story throughline, about whether Joanne will convert, illustrates how pressure to do so is counter-productive. It hints at what inclusive attitudes and communities would be like, including that partners from different faith backgrounds should be accepted exactly as they are.

By focusing on conversion, the show misses the opportunity to depict a relationship and community where an interfaith couple, and especially the partner from a different faith background, can find a sense of belonging. Perhaps that will come in season three?

Some articles on the show worth reading:

In other news:

  • I was delighted to see that Sheila Katz will be the Chief Jewish Life Officer at JFNA overseeing a portfolio that seeks to engage Jews of all backgrounds including “initiatives supporting multifaith and mixed-heritage families.”
  • A nice story from the Forward’s Bintel Brief about interfaith families and Jewish cemeteries; there’s not much new in the article, but it highlights the halachic/non-halachic divide on this issue.
  • 18Doors launched its largest B’Yachad cohort yet in Atlanta.
  • A nice story in The Conversation by Samira Mehta on interfaith weddings weaving traditions together.
  • Another negative story about Israel’s Interior Ministry making life difficult for converts.
  • Finally, speaking of pressure to convert – and I try to keep politics out of this newsletter – Vice President Vance seems to have applied some public pressure, then tried to walk it back hoping that his Hindu wife would become Catholic.

October 2024 News from the Center

|

Nobody Wants This

The news this month was pretty much all about the Netflix hit show, Nobody Wants This, in which “hot rabbi” Noah falls for Joanne who’s not Jewish; she says she’ll convert then realizes she’s not ready; he appears to choose to stay with her which means he won’t get the promotion to senior rabbi he’s always wanted.

The Forward published my take on it, What “Nobody Wants This” gets wrong about interfaith relationships today. I enjoyed watching the show. It depicts some aspects of Jewish life in a refreshing, positive way, while it’s portrayal of Jewish women is awful.

But the messaging about interfaith relationships is terrible. It suggests that nobody in the Jewish community wants interfaith relationships; that they don’t produce Jewish children; and that if the partner from a different faith background doesn’t convert, the Jewish partner will lose their Jewish identity (or in Rabbi Noah’s case, his dream to be senior rabbi).

While all of that is wrong, the show’s exaggerations do reflect an underlying reality – many interfaith couples do not feel a sense of belonging to the Jewish people, because of lingering negative attitudes about interfaith marriage. I’m hoping that Season Two will change the messaging and show a happy interfaith family raising children with Judaism; with Rabbi Noah becoming senior rabbi at a congregation that accepts him as intermarried; and perhaps even with Joanne taking an Introduction to Judaism course, whether or not it leads to conversion right away.

In a NY Times interview, the show’s co-producer, Sara Foster, says that “to draw an audience in for 10 episodes you need conflict.” I get that, and maybe what I’m hoping for doesn’t provide that. But given the messaging about interfaith marriage, let alone the stereotyping of Jewish women, it seems tone-deaf to me when her sister Erin Foster, the show’s writer and co-producer, says she feels fortunate to have shined “a positive light on Judaism and Jewish people and Jewish culture.” I feel the same way about Sara’s statement that “for there to be a Jewish romantic comedy that is number one across the world… is good for Jewish people.”

I tried to keep track of all of the writing about the show but can’t report on everything, let alone all the social media buzz. A Canadian academin, Celia Rothenberg, thinks that the stereotypes and depiction of interfaith marriage is harmful. I especially like Rabbi Denise Handlarski’s piece, in Hey Alma, I’m a Rabbi in an Interfaith Marriage — Here’s What I Think About ‘Nobody Wants This’; Lior Zaltman’s piece in Kveller, Should Jews Want Netflix’s ‘Nobody Wants This?’; Jessica Radloff’s piece in Glamour, Netflix’s Nobody Wants This and the Persistent Jewish Stereotype; and Keren McGinity’s piece in JTA, Netflix’s ‘Nobody Wants This’ casually celebrates Judaism. I want a second season.

There were other pieces in the NY Times and Time and Moment; an interview in the LA Times with and a profile of Erin Foster and her response to criticism of the show; a piece by Samira Mehta that puts the show in the context of past plays and movies featuring Jewish men dating women from different faith backgrounds; Rabbi Talia Kaplan explains “Why the charming ‘hot’ rabbi in ‘Nobody Wants This’ is bad for clergy and congregants everywhere”; an interesting podcast on the show with Conservative rabbis Michael Knopf and Jesse Olitzky; a piece by a British Reform rabbi; even a piece from Australia. Susan Katz Miller reasonably asked why Joanne had to be someone who is an ex-Christian (as opposed to from some other religious background) while “her people” – people who are practicing two faiths in an interfaith relationship – are never represented; she also objected to the pressure on Joanne to convert.

There were even commentaries from the Orthodox community. In a piece on Aish, a Jewish matchmaker says, not in an offensive way, that love cannot conquer all and that marrying within the faith is a foundational value that enriches our lives and communities.

But a piece in Jew In The City, by Allison Josephs, is offensive. She among other things refers to intermarriage as a “cardinal sin” that “leads to the extinction of the Jewish people” and says the non-Orthodox community is “marrying itself out of existence.” She says Rabbi Noah, by choosing Joanne, “becomes part of the extinction of the Jewish people.” Jew In The City describes itself as a nonprofit “dedicated to changing negative perceptions of religious Jews and making engaging and meaningful Orthodox Judaism known and accessible. This is achieved by highlighting an approach based on kindness, tolerance, sincerity, and critical thinking.” Tolerance?

Conservative Movement News

Just as this newsletter was about to be sent, a powerful essay appeared on Mark Hoffman’s Times of Israel blog: Too Little, Too Late for Conservative Judaism? Hoffman describes the movement’s recent efforts to reassess its approach to interfaith marriage, and discusses a very interesting-sounding presentation by Rabbi Aaron Brusso that I haven’t had a chance to fully watch yet. I’ll plan to comment more in the November email newsletter.

In Other News

This profile of Alexandra Meyer, tells about a young woman who grew up in an interfaith family, with a Jewish mother, with no synagogue or camp or bat mitzvah, who built a Jewish life through her own exploration as a late teen and in college, and is now the managing director of GatherDC,  a nonprofit that helps young adult Jews connect to Jewish life and to each other.